Case Summary: Madison Ashton v Estate of the late Richard Pratt
Written on the 18 February 2015 by Adrian Corbould
"Today the Court of Appeal handed down its decision in the matter of Madison Ashton against the Estate of the late 'Cardboard King', Richard Pratt, who was worth approximately $3 billion in his death in 2009."
"After his death, Ms Ashton claimed upon his Estate, which was represented by his Executor (his wife Jeanne), that in the early part of 2000 she and Mr Pratt had an agreement where in lieu or Ms Ashton giving up her profession as an escort she would become exclusive to Mr Pratt and he would setup a trust of $5 million for her children, give her an allowance of $500,000 a year, an allowance of $36,000 a year for accommodation and $30,000 a year for travel."
"Now, after his death in 2009, Ms Ashton made this claim upon the Estate and the Executor said 'No Way!'."
"What followed was Ms Ashton launched a civil claim in the Court of Equity, in the jurisdiction of equity, in the Supreme Court of New South Wales (NSW), which is the jurisdiction that regulates these Estate claims."
"And evidence that came out in that hearing was that in 2005 Ms Ashton signed a termination agreement with Mr Pratt saying that in acceptance of $150,000 she would walk away. The Court also found that, although it was likely that there were these discussion between Ms Ashton and Mr Pratt in the early part of 2000, those discussions did not form a legally binding agreement and Ms Ashton's claim was dismissed."
"Now, the only way to appeal that is to appeal to the Court of Appeal, which is the highest Court in NSW. To succeed in an appeal the applicant has to show that the Judge in the Supreme Court hearing made an error, which is very difficult. Especially in this matter where the Court accepted that there was this termination agreement."
"The three Judges in the Court of Appeal upheld the earlier decision and Ms Ashton's appeal was dismissed with costs. Meaning she now has to pay the legal costs of Mr Pratt's Estate and to run Supreme Court and Court of Appeal hearings would be in the hundreds of thousands of dollars."
"If you've been left out of a Will, if you need advice about contesting an Estate, or you're an Executor needing to defend a claim made on an Estate, please call me and we can discuss the matter further."
Author: Adrian Corbould
About: Adrian is an Accredited Specialist in Wills & Estates Law. He practises exclusively as a member of the Contested Wills & Estates team. For more than 10 years, Adrian has helped hundreds of clients, and his tenacity and experience make him one of the most sought after Will Contest Lawyers in New South Wales (NSW).Connect via: Twitter Google+ LinkedIn
Adrian Corbould is a Law Society Accredited Specialist in Wills & Estates Law. For more than 15 years he has helped hundreds of clients in contested estate matters. His tenacity and experience make him one of the most sought after Will Contest Lawyers in New South Wales (NSW).
Adrian is an Accredited Specialist within the Contested Wills & Estates Team. In certain circumstances, the team operates on a 'No Win, No Fee' basis. If you'd like to discuss your circumstances with a member of the team, call us and ask for a Free Appraisal.
We respond in 24 hours or less
Liability limited by a scheme approved under Professional Standards Legislation.