1300 124 524

Case Summary: Penninger v Penninger [2017] NSWSC 892

Written on the 24 November 2017

On 6 July 2017, the Supreme Court of NSW handed down its decision in the case of Penninger v Penninger [2017] NSWSC 892. In this case, the plaintiff was the daughter of the deceased and therefore an eligible person under s57(c) of the Succession Act 2006. It is important to note that the estate in this matter was a very small estate with a net value of approximately $139,000.

This was a matter in which the plaintiff succeeded in her application for family provision claim, even though she was out of time.

The two main procedural issues dealt with were as follows:
  1. Plaintiff's application made out of time; and
  2. Administration of the deceased's estate.

The Court considered that the executor of the estate, had done "nothing to administer the estate until about six years after the death of the deceased".

"The executor had been living on the deceased's property since the death of the deceased."

"Having found that the plaintiff had a reasonable claim the Court was of the view that sufficient cause had been shown for the making of her application. Thus the date of her application was extended to the date of the filing of the summons."

"Consistent with prevailing community standards, the Court was satisfied that adequate provision for the proper maintenance or advancement in life of the plaintiff had not been made by the Will of the deceased."

She was awarded a lump sum of $17,500 out of the deceased' estate.

The Court ordered that administration of the deceased's estate be granted to the Plaintiff for the purposes only of permitting her application for family provision claim to be dealt with.

Adrian Corbould

Adrian Corbould is a Law Society Accredited Specialist in Wills & Estates Law. For more than 15 years he has helped hundreds of clients in contested estate matters. His tenacity and experience make him one of the most sought after Will Contest Lawyers in New South Wales (NSW).

Adrian is an Accredited Specialist within the Contested Wills & Estates Team. In certain circumstances, the team operates on a 'No Win, No Fee' basis. If you'd like to discuss your circumstances with a member of the team, call us and ask for a Free Appraisal.


Contact Us Now

We respond in 24 hours or less

Your Details

Liability Limited By A Scheme Under Professional Standards Legislation